Advice Quote by Daniel Fried
“The same people the Americans sent over - that we sent over to advise the Russians, we also sent over to advise the Poles about how to build a post-communist economy. Same people, same advice, with radically different results, which leads to suspicion it's not our advice which was the crucial variable. It was the Poles, on one hand, and the Russians on the other. The Poles succeeded; the Russians didn't. Don't blame us.”
About This Quote
Source Interview: Policy analysis discussion, 2021
The quote argues that differing outcomes in Poland and Russia stem from local factors, not the advice given, suggesting that context matters more than external guidance.
In simple terms: Different results are due to local conditions, not the advice itself.
Key Takeaway
Consider local context before blaming advice.
Themes
politics
policy
history
comparative analysis
Mood
analytical
critical
Type
political
historical
When to use this quote
- economic reform
- foreign aid
- international consulting
Key Concepts
contextualism
agency
effectiveness
Questions to Reflect On
- What local factors contributed to Poland’s success?
- How can advisors better account for cultural differences?
A Different Perspective
Advice may still be flawed regardless of context.
![“The Russians didn't hack the DNC servers. The Russians didn't interfere in the election [2016]. And if you get a Democrat in the know to sit down and honestly tell you off the record, they'll admit it.” quote by Rush Limbaugh](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/b75/rush-limbaugh-28_democrat_the-russians-didn-t-hack-the-dnc-servers_1122406.jpg)
![“[Russians] want to bring us down to make them feel better about the failure of the Soviet Union. I don't mean bring us down as in collapse, but bring us down a notch in a big way.” quote by Daniel Fried](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/1aa/daniel-fried-8925_bigs_russians-want-to-bring-us-down-to-make-t_348977.jpg)
![“In my view, [Vladimir] Putin despises the West in general and the United States in particular, both for who we are, our liberal values, and for what we've done, which is to take down the Soviet Empire.” quote by Daniel Fried](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/bcd/daniel-fried-8925_despise_in-my-view-vladimir-putin-despises-the-w_592889.jpg)
