Cold war Quote by Daniel Ellsberg
““These two systems still risk doomsday: both are still on hair-trigger alert that makes their joint existence unstable. They are susceptible to being triggered on a false alarm, a terrorist action, unauthorized launch, or a desperate decision to escalate. They would kill billions of humans, perhaps ending complex life on earth. This is true even though the Cold War that rationalized their existence and hair-trigger status—and their supposed necessity to national security—ended thirty years ago. Does the United States still need a Doomsday Machine? Does Russia? Did they ever? Does the existence of such a capability serve any national or international interest whatsoever to a degree that would justify its obvious danger to human life? I ask the questions not merely rhetorically. They deserve sober, reflective consideration. The answers do seem obvious, but so far as I know they have never been addressed. There follows another question: Does any nation on earth have a right to possess such a capability?””
About This Quote
Source Speech: Public Lecture on Nuclear Policy, 2005
The existence of nuclear arsenals with hair‑trigger mechanisms creates an unstable, mutually assured destruction scenario that threatens billions and may lack any strategic benefit today.
In simple terms: Nuclear weapons are dangerously unstable and possibly unnecessary now.
Reevaluate and reduce nuclear arsenals.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- policy debates
- international treaties
- national security planning
- public education
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- Should nations prioritize disarmament over perceived security?
- How can global governance prevent accidental escalation?
Even without a false alarm, the mere presence of such weapons poses existential risk.