Moral Quote by Dan Barker
““There is no “universal moral urge” and not all ethical systems agree. Polygamy, human sacrifice, infanticide, cannibalism (Eucharist), wife beating, self-mutilation, foot binding, preemptive war, torture of prisoners, circumcision, female genital mutilation, racism, sexism, punitive amputation, castration and incest are perfectly “moral” in certain cultures. Is god confused?””
About This Quote
Source Debate: Ethical relativism discussion, 2021
The statement argues that moral standards vary across cultures, listing extreme practices and questioning divine consistency.
In simple terms: Morality differs by culture; even extreme acts can be seen as moral locally.
Key Takeaway
Consider cultural context when judging moral issues.
Themes
ethics
culture
relativism
morality
Mood
critical
inquisitive
Type
analytical
philosophical
When to use this quote
- anthropology classes
- policy making
- intercultural dialogue
- human rights advocacy
Key Concepts
cultural relativism
moral pluralism
ethical debate
Questions to Reflect On
- What criteria should limit cultural practices?
- How do we balance respect and condemnation?
A Different Perspective
Assuming all cultural practices are equally moral can ignore harm and universal rights.
