Books Quote by Book of Eli Movie
![“Carnegie: [Carnegie inspects the book] Ask and you shall receive. God is good, is he not? Eli: All the time. Carnegie: Not all the time. [shoots Eli]” quote by Book of Eli Movie](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/03e/book-of-eli-movie-23864_books_carnegie-carnegie-inspects-the-book-ask_1453330.jpg)
““Carnegie: [Carnegie inspects the book] Ask and you shall receive. God is good, is he not? Eli: All the time. Carnegie: Not all the time. [shoots Eli]””
About This Quote
Source Film: The Book of Eli, 2010
A character uses a rhetorical question about divine goodness to justify violent action, highlighting the misuse of faith for personal motives.
In simple terms: Faith is twisted to excuse violence.
Key Takeaway
Question motives behind invoking religion.
Themes
faith
violence
morality
power
deception
Mood
conflicted
critical
thoughtful
Type
dialogue
dramatic
cautionary
When to use this quote
- political rhetoric
- religious discourse
- personal justification
- conflict resolution
Key Concepts
theodicy
ethical relativism
authority
manipulation
Questions to Reflect On
- How does invoking higher power affect ethical decisions?
- When is faith a cover for personal agenda?
A Different Perspective
Faith can be weaponized, not always a moral guide.
![“Eli: [whispering to Solara, after seeing the graves George and Martha made] We gotta go now. Solara: They killed all these people. Eli: Not just killed them, they ate them. Solara: Her hands, her hands were shaking. Eli: Too much human meat. Let's go.” quote by Book of Eli Movie](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/1a0/book-of-eli-movie-23864_killed_eli-whispering-to-solara-after-seeing-th_2688604.jpg)
![“[They're in the middle of a gun fight with Carnegie's men] Solara: You know that voice you heard, did it say anything about this. Eli: We'll get out both of us. George: What about us? Eli: Didn't say anything about you.” quote by Book of Eli Movie](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/226/book-of-eli-movie-23864_fight_they-re-in-the-middle-of-a-gun-fight-wit_2270018.jpg)
![“Lombardi: [to his assistant] Could you get us some writing paper, please. Eli: A lot of it. A whole lot of it.” quote by Book of Eli Movie](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/018/book-of-eli-movie-23864_movie-quote_lombardi-to-his-assistant-could-you-get_1083863.jpg)
![“Solara: You know, you say you've been walking for thirty years, right? Eli: Right? Solara: Have you ever thought that maybe you were lost? Eli: Nope. Solara: Well, how do you know that you're walking in the right direction? Eli: I walk by faith, not by sight. Solara: [sighs] What does that mean?…” quote by Book of Eli Movie](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/69c/book-of-eli-movie-23864_book_solara-you-know-you-say-you-ve-been-walk_532954.jpg)
