Skip to content

Books Quote by Benoît Peeters

“When he read the text for the first time, Alan Bass, who was far from being a novice, had the impression that it would be as complicated as trying to translate Joyce into French. Derrida acknowledged that the ‘Envois’ were very encrypted and agreed to provide Bass with explanations, comments, and…” quote by Benoît Peeters
Download Open image
““When he read the text for the first time, Alan Bass, who was far from being a novice, had the impression that it would be as complicated as trying to translate Joyce into French. Derrida acknowledged that the ‘Envois’ were very encrypted and agreed to provide Bass with explanations, comments, and suggestions whenever required. ‘Most of this work was done by letter,’ Alan Bass recalls. He would send me my pages back with many annotations. But we had at least one long session together in a railway station buffet, while he was between trains. There were many details that would have escaped my notice if he hadn’t drawn my attention to them. For example, in the sentence ‘Est-ce taire un nom?’ [‘Is this to keep silence about a name?’], you also have to read ‘Esther’, which is one of the forenames of his mother, but also a biblical name that plays a very active part in the book. In spite of all my efforts, many of these effects disappeared in the translation.15 Hans-Joachim Metzger, the German translator of The Post Card, would find the work equally demanding. ‘On reading your questions,’ Derrida wrote to him, ‘I see yet again that you have read the text better than I have. That’s why a translator is absolutely unbearable, and the better he is, the scarier he is: the super-ego in person.””

Benoît Peeters

About This Quote

Source Interview: Discussion on translation challenges, 2008

Translating complex philosophical texts requires deep cultural and linguistic insight, making the translator's role uniquely demanding.

In simple terms: Translating dense ideas needs deep cultural and linguistic knowledge.

Key Takeaway

Embrace collaborative, detailed analysis when translating.

Themes

translation philosophy language collaboration interpretation

Mood

thoughtful intricate

Type

literary scholarly

When to use this quote

  • academic publishing
  • literary translation
  • cross‑cultural projects
  • editing
  • peer review

Key Concepts

semantic nuance intertextuality authorial intent

Questions to Reflect On

  • What methods help uncover hidden meanings in texts?
  • How does collaboration improve translation fidelity?
A Different Perspective

Even experts may miss subtle references without close collaboration.

3.2 out of 5 (5 ratings)

More by Benoît Peeters

Explore all 41 Benoît Peeters quotes

More Books quotes

Browse all 59,485 Books quotes