Assuming Quote by Allen W. Wood
“Kant is not saying - about freedom or any other subject - anything of the form: "Not-p but we must assume that p." That's close to self-contradictory, like Moore's paradox: "p, but I don't believe that p".”
About This Quote
The statement resembles a self‑contradictory claim, akin to Moore's paradox, where one asserts a proposition while denying belief in it, highlighting a logical inconsistency.
In simple terms: It points out a logical inconsistency similar to Moore's paradox.
Key Takeaway
Watch for hidden contradictions in arguments.
Themes
logic
philosophy
argumentation
critical thinking
Mood
analytical
inquisitive
Type
philosophical
academic
When to use this quote
- debate preparation
- essay writing
- critical analysis
- teaching philosophy
Key Concepts
paradox
self‑contradiction
epistemology
Questions to Reflect On
- Is the analogy accurate for Kant's position?
- How do we resolve such paradoxes in reasoning?
A Different Perspective
The comparison may oversimplify Kant's nuanced views on necessity and belief.
![“[The Head of Radio Three] had been ensnared by the Music Director of the college and a Professor of Philosophy. These two were busy explaining to the harassed man that the phrase "too much Mozart" was, given any reasonable definition of those three words, an inherently self-contradictory…” quote by Douglas Adams](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/289/douglas-adams-122_argument_the-head-of-radio-three-had-been-ensnare_934848.jpg)
![“Sholem [a painter] was saying that freedom, for him, is having the technical facility to be able to execute whatever he wants, just whatever image he has in his mind. But that's not freedom! That's control, or power. Whereas I think Margaux understands freedom to be the freedom to take risks, the…” quote by Sheila Heti](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/9b5/sheila-heti-2776_art_sholem-a-painter-was-saying-that-freedom_1434124.jpg)
