Clear Quote by Alexander Hamilton
“Jurors should acquit, even against the judge's instruction . . . if exercising their judgment with discretion and honesty they have a clear conviction the charge of the court is wrong.”
About This Quote
Source Letter: Federalist Papers, 1788
Jurors must follow conscience over a's instruction when they believe a charge is unjust.
In simple terms: Juries should override judges if they see a mistake.
Key Takeaway
Trust juror discretion for justice.
Themes
justice
jurisprudence
ethics
Mood
serious
thoughtful
Type
legal
ethical
When to use this quote
- court trials
- jury deliberations
- legal reform
- civil rights
Key Concepts
legal theory
democracy
Questions to Reflect On
- When should jurors defer to legal guidance?
- What safeguards protect against wrongful acquittals?
A Different Perspective
Jurors may lack expertise to assess complex law.
![“If the question [before justices of the peace] relate to any point of public liberty, or if it be one of those in which the judges may be suspected of bias, the jury undertake to decide both law and fact.” quote by Thomas Jefferson](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/f8a/thomas-jefferson-43_bias_if-the-question-before-justices-of-the-p_982924.jpg)
![“[N]o American should retreat an inch on the right of jurors to acquit if they perceive the law or its administration to be unjust.” quote by Charley Reese](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/83e/charley-reese-14592_administration_n-o-american-should-retreat-an-inch-on-t_515058.jpg)
![“[W]ar is a question, under our constitution, not of Executive, but of Legislative cognizance. It belongs to Congress to say whether the Nation shall of choice dismiss the olive branch and unfurl the banners of War.” quote by Alexander Hamilton](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/bd8/alexander-hamilton-619_banner_w-ar-is-a-question-under-our-constitutio_33383.jpg)
![“It is one thing to be subordinate to the laws, and another [for the Executive] to be dependent on the legislative body. The first comports with, the last violates, the fundamental principles of good government; and, whatever may be the forms of the Constitution, unites all power in the same hands.” quote by Alexander Hamilton](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/be4/alexander-hamilton-619_body_it-is-one-thing-to-be-subordinate-to-the_129196.jpg)
![“We have no clear ideas of the agency of [demonic] spirits, nor is it necessary. The Scripture says little to satisfy our curiosity; but tells us plainly that he is always watching us, and desiring to sift us as wheat. I believe we give him no more than his due, when we charge him with having a…” quote by John Newton](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/c75/john-newton-6629_abundance_we-have-no-clear-ideas-of-the-agency-of_2907.jpg)
