Skip to content

Israel Quote by Alex von Tunzelmann

“The Israeli border police guarding the central region near the Jordanian border had been told to take all measures necessary to keep order that evening. The local colonel, Issachar Shadmi, decided that this meant setting a curfew for Palestinian Arab villages, from five p.m. to six a.m. The news…” quote by Alex von Tunzelmann
Download Open image
““The Israeli border police guarding the central region near the Jordanian border had been told to take all measures necessary to keep order that evening. The local colonel, Issachar Shadmi, decided that this meant setting a curfew for Palestinian Arab villages, from five p.m. to six a.m. The news of the curfew was broadcast over the radio the same day it went into force. The border police unit commanders in the region were informed of the order by their commanding officer, Major Shmuel Malinki. Malinki implied that, in the event of anyone breaking the curfew, the police could shoot to kill. Several platoons were charged with informing villagers in person. At the village of Kfar Kassem (or Kafr Qasim), close to the border with the Jordanian-controlled West Bank, a platoon arrived to announce the news—but too late in the day. They were told that many of the village’s agricultural workers were already out at work, mostly picking olives. After five p.m., the villagers returned as expected: a mixed crowd of men and women, boys and girls, riding on bicycles, wagons, and trucks. Even though he knew these civilians would not have heard about the curfew through no fault of their own, the unit commander Lieutenant Gabriel Dahan determined that they were in violation of it and therefore should be shot. Out of all the unit commanders given this order, Dahan was the only one to enforce it.16 As each small group of villagers arrived, the border police opened fire. Forty-three civilians were killed and thirteen injured. The dead were mostly children aged between eight and seventeen: twenty-three of them, plus fourteen men and six women. It was said that one nine-year-old girl was shot twenty-eight times. Another little girl watched as her eleven-year-old cousin was shot. He was dragged indoors and died in his grandfather’s arms, blood pouring from the bullet wound in his chest. Laborers were ordered off their trucks in small groups, lined up, and executed. There were clashes between Arabs and border police that evening in which six more Arabs were killed. The order to kill had not come from the top. It was traced back conclusively only as far as Major Malinki. When Ben-Gurion heard about the massacre, he was furious, telling his cabinet that the officers who had shot civilians should be hanged in Kfar Kassem’s town square.17 Yet the Israeli government covered the incident up with a press blackout lasting two months.””

Alex von Tunzelmann

About This Quote

Source Historical Account: Kafr Qasim Massacre, 1956

The narrative describes a tragic enforcement of a curfew that led to civilian deaths, highlighting the misuse of lethal orders.

In simple terms: A curfew was enforced violently, killing many civilians.

Key Takeaway

Beware of blind obedience to lethal orders.

Themes

military ethics human rights obedience

Mood

somber reflective

Type

historical educational

When to use this quote

  • military training
  • human rights education
  • policy review

Key Concepts

law military command civilian protection

Questions to Reflect On

  • What safeguards prevent unlawful orders?
  • How can societies hold perpetrators accountable?
A Different Perspective

The account may lack perspectives of the soldiers involved.

3.1 out of 5 (9 ratings)

More by Alex von Tunzelmann

Explore all 14 Alex von Tunzelmann quotes

More Israel quotes

Browse all 16,724 Israel quotes