Skip to content

Bible Quote by Alan Dundes University of California

“The Gospel of Mark has some major shortcomings: It contains no birth narrative; it implies that Jesus, a repentant sinner, became the Son of God only at his baptism; it recounts no resurrection appearances; and it ends with the very unsatisfactory notion that the women who found the Empty Tomb…” quote by Alan Dundes University of California
Download Open image
““The Gospel of Mark has some major shortcomings: It contains no birth narrative; it implies that Jesus, a repentant sinner, became the Son of God only at his baptism; it recounts no resurrection appearances; and it ends with the very unsatisfactory notion that the women who found the Empty Tomb were too afraid to speak to anyone about it. Moreover, Mark includes very little of Jesus' teachings; worse yet, (from Matthew's point of view) he even misunderstood totally the purpose of Jesus' use of parables. Indeed, by the last two decades of the first century, Mark's theology seemed already old-fashioned and even slightly suggestive of heresy. So, working apparently without knowledge of each other, within perhaps twenty or thirty years after Mark, two authors (or Christian groups), now known to us as "Matthew" and "Luke" (and even a third, in the view of some-"John') set about rewriting and correcting the first unsatisfactory Gospel.””

Alan Dundes University of California

About This Quote

The Gospel of Mark is seen as incomplete and outdated compared to later Gospels, prompting revisions by Matthew and Luke.

In simple terms: Mark's Gospel lacks key narratives and teachings, leading later authors to rewrite it.

Key Takeaway

Recognize gaps in sources and seek fuller perspectives.

Themes

biblical criticism textual analysis historical context

Mood

critical inquisitive

Type

biblical criticism:1 Bible study:1 Gospel:1 Gospel-of-mark:1 Gospels:1 Mark:1 New testament:1 Point of view:1 Son of god:0 Thirty years:0 Gospel Mark:0 Mark Theology:0 Unsatisfactory Gospel:1

When to use this quote

  • academic study
  • sermon preparation
  • faith education
  • interfaith dialogue

Key Concepts

canon formation hermeneutics theology

Questions to Reflect On

  • How do we assess the reliability of ancient texts?
  • What drives revisions in religious narratives?
A Different Perspective

Later Gospels may also reflect biases of their authors.

3.5 out of 5 (5 ratings)

More Bible quotes

Browse all 8,465 Bible quotes