Skip to content

The old doctrine that God wanted man to do something for…

“The old doctrine that God wanted man to do something for him, and that he kept a watchful eye upon all the children of men; that he rewarded the virtuous and punished the wicked, is gradually fading from the mind. We know that some of the worst men have what the world calls success. We know that…” quote by Robert Green Ingersoll
Download Open image
“The old doctrine that God wanted man to do something for him, and that he kept a watchful eye upon all the children of men; that he rewarded the virtuous and punished the wicked, is gradually fading from the mind. We know that some of the worst men have what the world calls success. We know that some of the best men lie upon the straw of failure. We know that honesty goes hungry, while larceny sits at the banquet. We know that the vicious have every physical comfort, while the virtuous are often clad in rags.”

Robert Green Ingersoll

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

Traditional belief that divine justice rewards virtue and punishes vice is eroding; reality shows success often goes to the immoral while the honest suffer.

In simple terms: Divine justice is not reliable; success and suffering are not moral indicators.

Key Takeaway

Don’t rely on moral expectations of fate; act ethically regardless of outcomes.

Themes

justice morality success honesty inequality

Mood

reflective critical thoughtful

Type

philosophical social commentary

When to use this quote

  • business decisions
  • personal relationships
  • political activism
  • philanthropy
  • career choices

Key Concepts

theology social critique ethical relativism

Questions to Reflect On

  • How do you define success beyond moral judgments?
  • What role should personal integrity play when outcomes seem unfair?
A Different Perspective

It may overlook that many people find meaning and community through faith despite apparent injustices.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Robert Green Ingersoll

Explore all 640 Robert Green Ingersoll quotes

More Banquets quotes

Browse all 132 Banquets quotes