Suppose whether or not someone tells me a lie depends only…
“Suppose whether or not someone tells me a lie depends only on whether he wants to, but he is morally indifferent, he doesn't care much about the truth or about me, and his self interest, which he worships, tells him to lie, and so it comes about that given his psychology, it is a forgone conclusion that he will lie to me. I think in this case he is still blameworthy, and that implies, among other things, that he did something he ought not do.”
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
A person who lies out of self‑interest, even if indifferent to truth, is still morally blameworthy because the act violates a duty not to deceive.
In simple terms: Self‑interested lying is blameworthy.
Key Takeaway
Recognize duty to truth despite motives.
Themes
ethics
responsibility
truthfulness
Mood
thoughtful
critical
Type
philosophical
ethical
When to use this quote
- personal relationships
- legal testimony
- business negotiations
- media reporting
Key Concepts
moral philosophy
intentionality
blame
Questions to Reflect On
- Is moral blame tied to intent or outcome?
- Can indifference excuse deception?
A Different Perspective
If indifference removes moral concern, accountability may be contested.