Skip to content

I don't think that you can dispose of the constructive and…

“I don't think that you can dispose of the constructive and inventive things that America is doing - and say, "Oh we aren't doing anything anymore and we are living off of what the poor Chinese do." It is more complicated than that. There is the example of Detroit which was once a very prosperous…” quote by Jane Jacobs
Download Open image
“I don't think that you can dispose of the constructive and inventive things that America is doing - and say, "Oh we aren't doing anything anymore and we are living off of what the poor Chinese do." It is more complicated than that. There is the example of Detroit which was once a very prosperous and diverse city. And look what happened when it just specialized on automobiles. Look at Manchester when it specialized in those dark satanic mills, when it specialized in textiles. It was supposed to be the city of the future.”

Jane Jacobs

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

Economic specialization can weaken cities, leading to decline; diversified economies foster resilience.

In simple terms: Cities need varied industries to thrive.

Key Takeaway

Promote economic diversity.

Themes

urban planning economics diversification resilience industrial policy

Mood

analytical cautious

Type

urban economic

When to use this quote

  • city governance
  • business strategy
  • education programs
  • investment decisions

Key Concepts

creative destruction regional development social equity

Questions to Reflect On

  • What sectors could a city diversify into?
  • How to balance specialization with resilience?
A Different Perspective

Specialization can create short‑term gains but long‑term vulnerability.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Jane Jacobs

Explore all 193 Jane Jacobs quotes

More America quotes

Browse all 20,382 America quotes