There are some animal advocates who say that to maintain…
““There are some animal advocates who say that to maintain that veganism is the moral baseline is objectionable because it is “judgmental,” or constitutes a judgment that veganism is morally preferable to vegetarianism and a condemnation that vegetarians (or other consumers of animal products) are “bad” people. Yes to the first part; no to the second. There is no coherent distinction between flesh and other animal products. They are all the same and we cannot justify consuming any of them. To say that you do not eat flesh but that you eat dairy or eggs or whatever, or that you don’t wear fur but you wear leather or wool, is like saying that you eat the meat from spotted cows but not from brown cows; it makers no sense whatsoever. The supposed “line” between meat and everything else is just a fantasy–an arbitrary distinction that is made to enable some exploitation to be segmented off and regarded as “better” or as morally acceptable. This is not a condemnation of vegetarians who are not vegans; it is, however, a plea to those people to recognize their actions do not conform with a moral principle that they claim to accept and that all animal products are the result of imposing suffering and death on sentient beings. It is not a matter of judging individuals; it is, however, a matter of judging practices and institutions. And that is a necessary component of ethical living.””
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
The argument claims that distinguishing veganism from other animal product consumption is arbitrary; all animal products cause suffering, so ethical consistency demands rejecting all.
In simple terms: All animal products cause suffering; ethical consistency requires rejecting all.
Reject all animal products for moral consistency.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- dietary choices
- policy advocacy
- consumer behavior
- institutional reform
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How can we address perceived moral judgment in promoting veganism?
- What practical steps can individuals take to align actions with this ethic?
Some argue veganism is judgmental; critics may see it as impractical.