Skip to content

On coming to America I had the same hopes as have most…

“On coming to America I had the same hopes as have most European immigrants and the same disillusionment, though the latter affected me more keenly and more deeply. The immigrant without money and without connections is not permitted to cherish the comforting illusion that America is a benevolent…” quote by Emma Goldman
Download Open image
““On coming to America I had the same hopes as have most European immigrants and the same disillusionment, though the latter affected me more keenly and more deeply. The immigrant without money and without connections is not permitted to cherish the comforting illusion that America is a benevolent uncle who assumes a tender and impartial guardianship of nephews and nieces. I soon learned that in a republic there are myriad ways by which the strong, the cunning, the rich can seize power and hold it. I saw the many work for small wages which kept them always on the borderline of want for the few who made huge profits. I saw the courts, the halls of legislation, the press, and the schools--in fact every avenue of education and protection--effectively used as an instrument for the safeguarding of a minority, while the masses were denied every right. I found that the politicians knew how to befog every issue, how to control public opinion and manipulate votes to their own advantage and to that of their financial and industrial allies. This was the picture of democracy I soon discovered on my arrival in the United States. Fundamentally there have been few changes since that time.””

Emma Goldman

About This Quote

This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.

The quote critiques the myth of American meritocracy, exposing how power and wealth manipulate institutions to favor elites while marginalizing the poor and immigrants.

In simple terms: America isn’t as fair as it seems; the rich control many systems.

Key Takeaway

Recognize systemic bias and seek collective action.

Themes

inequality power immigration democracy elitism

Mood

critical skeptical determined

Type

political social commentary

When to use this quote

  • Labor organizing
  • immigrant advocacy
  • policy reform
  • education outreach
  • media literacy

Key Concepts

Social stratification institutional corruption economic exploitation

Questions to Reflect On

  • How do you confront systemic oppression personally?
  • What collective steps can reduce elite dominance?
A Different Perspective

The analysis may overlook individual agency and successful upward mobility stories.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★ No ratings yet

More by Emma Goldman

Explore all 368 Emma Goldman quotes

More America quotes

Browse all 20,382 America quotes