I soon had an occasion to apply what I had learned from…
““I soon had an occasion to apply what I had learned from Feller. The Yom Kippur War broke out in 1973, and my only significant contribution to the war effort was to advise high officers in the Israeli Air Force to stop an investigation. The air war initially went quite badly for Israel, because of the unexpectedly good performance of Egyptian ground-to-air missiles. Losses were high, and they appeared to be unevenly distributed. I was told of two squadrons flying from the same base, one of which had lost four planes while the other had lost none. An inquiry was initiated in the hope of learning what it was that the unfortunate squadron was doing wrong. There was no prior reason to believe that one of the squadrons was more effective than the other, and no operational differences were found, but of course the lives of the pilots differed in many random ways, including, as I recall, how often they went home between missions and something about the conduct of debriefings. My advice was that the command should accept that the different outcomes were due to blind luck, and that the interviewing of the pilots should stop. I reasoned that luck was the most likely answer, that a random search for a nonobvious cause was hopeless, and that in the meantime the pilots in the squadron that had sustained losses did not need the extra burden of being made to feel that they and their dead friends were at fault.””
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
When outcomes differ due to chance, searching for hidden causes wastes effort; accept randomness and stop blaming individuals.
In simple terms: Accept luck, stop needless investigations.
Focus on controllable factors.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- military analysis
- corporate performance reviews
- sports coaching
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How can leaders convey randomness without demotivating?
- When is it appropriate to investigate further?
Randomness can be hard to communicate to teams.