Suppose, however, that God did give this law to the Jews…
“Suppose, however, that God did give this law to the Jews, and did tell them that whenever a man preached a heresy, or proposed to worship any other God that they should kill him; and suppose that afterward this same God took upon himself flesh, and came to this very chosen people and taught a different religion, and that thereupon the Jews crucified him; I ask you, did he not reap exactly what he had sown? What right would this god have to complain of a crucifixion suffered in accordance with his own command?”
About This Quote
This interpretation was drafted with AI assistance. It is one reading of the quote, not the author's own explanation.
A paradoxical critique of divine command theory, highlighting the inconsistency of a deity demanding violence then suffering that same violence.
In simple terms: Points out the contradiction in a god ordering death then being killed.
Key Takeaway
Recognize logical inconsistencies in moral authority.
Themes
theology
paradox
morality
justice
Mood
thoughtful
critical
Type
philosophical
theological
When to use this quote
- religious debate
- ethical discussions
- philosophical analysis
Key Concepts
Divine command theory
hypocrisy
retributive justice
Questions to Reflect On
- What does this say about the nature of divine authority?
- Can moral commands be self‑contradictory?
A Different Perspective
The argument assumes a literal interpretation of ancient law; modern contexts differ.