Skip to content

Good thing Quote by William Donaldson

“Utilitarianism: If we Britiash were Utilitarians we would have to believe that imprisoning the innocent and torturing suspects was justified if the Home Secretary thought it a good thing for our peace of mind.” quote by William Donaldson
Download Open image
““Utilitarianism: If we Britiash were Utilitarians we would have to believe that imprisoning the innocent and torturing suspects was justified if the Home Secretary thought it a good thing for our peace of mind.””

William Donaldson

About This Quote

Source Satire: Article “The Utilitarian Dilemma”, 2005

He mocks the absurdity of applying utilitarian logic to justify immoral acts for perceived peace.

In simple terms: Utilitarianism can be twisted to excuse cruelty for peace.

Key Takeaway

Question moral justifications that ignore rights.

Themes

ethics politics utilitarianism justice peace

Mood

skeptical provocative serious

Type

philosophical political

When to use this quote

  • debating policy ethics
  • examining law enforcement practices
  • teaching moral reasoning
  • critiquing political rhetoric

Key Concepts

moral philosophy political satire human rights

Questions to Reflect On

  • Is peace ever worth sacrificing innocence?
  • How do we balance security and rights?
A Different Perspective

Oversimplifies complex moral decisions; may ignore real threats.

5.0 out of 5 (9 ratings)

More by William Donaldson

Explore all 28 William Donaldson quotes

More Good thing quotes

Browse all 6,343 Good thing quotes