Argument Quote by Victor J. Stenger
“The argument from design stands or falls on whether it can be demonstrated that some aspect of the universe such as its origin or biological life could not have come about naturally. The burden of proof is ... on the supernaturalist to demonstrate that something from outside nature must be introduced to explain the data.”
About This Quote
Source Book: The Fallacy of Fine Tuning, Victor J. Stenger, 2011
The design argument hinges on proving that natural explanations are insufficient, placing the burden of proof on supernatural claims.
In simple terms: Design argument requires proving natural explanations fail.
Key Takeaway
Question supernatural claims and demand evidence.
Themes
science
philosophy
religion
burden of proof
Mood
analytical
skeptical
Type
scientific
philosophical
When to use this quote
- debates on origins
- science education
- public policy
- theology discussions
Key Concepts
epistemology
argument from design
Questions to Reflect On
- What evidence would convince you of design?
- How do we assess unexplained phenomena?
A Different Perspective
Natural explanations may be incomplete, leaving room for speculation.
![“For centuries the most powerful argument for God's existence from the physical world was the so-called argument from design: Living things are so beautiful and elegant and so apparently purposeful, they could only have been made by an intelligent designer. But [Charles] Darwin provided a simpler…” quote by Richard Dawkins](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/aee/richard-dawkins-115_adaptive_for-centuries-the-most-powerful-argument_2563841.jpg)
![“Until recent times, absence of evidence for his [Jehovah's] existence has not been sufficient to rule him out. However, we now have enough knowledge that we can identify many places where there should be evidence, but there is not. The absence of that evidence allows us to rule out the existence…” quote by Victor J. Stenger](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/923/victor-j-stenger-16236_absence_until-recent-times-absence-of-evidence-f_385888.jpg)
