Skip to content

Obeyed Orders Quote by Ulysses S. Grant

“The operator refused point blank to turn over the key to Captain Comstock as directed by me, stating that his orders from the War Department were not to give it to anybody—the commanding general or any one else. I told him I would see whether he would or not. He said that if he did he would be…” quote by Ulysses S. Grant
Download Open image
““The operator refused point blank to turn over the key to Captain Comstock as directed by me, stating that his orders from the War Department were not to give it to anybody—the commanding general or any one else. I told him I would see whether he would or not. He said that if he did he would be punished. I told him if he did not he most certainly would be punished. Finally, seeing that punishment was certain if he refused longer to obey my order, and being somewhat remote (even if he was not protected altogether from the consequences of his disobedience to his orders) from the War Department, he yielded. When I returned from Knoxville I found quite a commotion. The operator had been reprimanded very severely and ordered to be relieved. I informed the Secretary of War, or his assistant secretary in charge of the telegraph, Stager, that the man could not be relieved, for he had only obeyed my orders. It was absolutely necessary for me to have the cipher, and the man would most certainly have been punished if he had not delivered it; that they would have to punish me if they punished anybody, or words to that effect.””

Ulysses S. Grant

About This Quote

Source Letter: Personal correspondence, 1864, Civil War

Grant describes coercing a telegraph operator to surrender a cipher, emphasizing the moral ambiguity of using threats to achieve strategic goals.

In simple terms: Grant forced a man to give up a secret key by threatening punishment.

Key Takeaway

Power can compel compliance, but raises ethical concerns.

Themes

authority ethics military communication coercion

Mood

tense conflicted

Type

historical military ethical

When to use this quote

  • civil war command
  • intelligence gathering
  • telegraph operation
  • military hierarchy

Key Concepts

strategic decisionmaking obedience moral dilemma

Questions to Reflect On

  • Is it ever justified to threaten subordinates for critical information?
  • How does coercion affect morale and loyalty?
A Different Perspective

The tactic may achieve short‑term objectives but erodes trust and can cause long‑term damage.

3.6 out of 5 (9 ratings)

More by Ulysses S. Grant

Explore all 208 Ulysses S. Grant quotes

More Obeyed Orders quotes

Browse all 4 Obeyed Orders quotes