First time Quote by Suzy Hansen
““We in the West still seemed to believe the old story of how a man transformed an Islamic empire into a secular republic: Atatürk came along, changed some rules, the people followed. Old Turkish textbooks didn’t portray the suppression of Islam as anything other than a liberation. But I began to question for the first time what it was like to suddenly lose your language, your mode of dress, your idea of the world. My assumption had been that any social revolution that resulted in a country becoming more “modern,” in the American sense, must have been a good thing. In Turkey, not only had this revolution been damaging, but it hadn’t worked. It was strange, I was as critical of the United States as I thought one could be. But at that point, I still had no idea that with even those political views came an unassailable, perhaps unconscious faith in my country’s inherent goodness, as well as in my country’s Western way of living, and perhaps in my own inherent, God-given, Christian-American goodness as well.””
About This Quote
Source Article: The New Yorker, “Atatürk’s Legacy,” Suzy Hansen, 2020
The author reflects on how Western narratives glorify secular reforms, overlooking the loss of cultural identity and the complexities of modernization.
In simple terms: Western praise for secular change can ignore cultural costs.
Question assumptions about progress.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- education curricula
- policy analysis
- personal reflection
- media critique
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How do you define “modern” for a society?
- What voices are missing in dominant narratives?
May oversimplify diverse experiences.