Ads Quote by Susan Fiske
“If people are going to do post-publication peer review, they need to abide by the same rules as they abide by for pre-publication peer review: not being ad hominem, being respectful, giving the author a chance to respond in a reasonable way.”
About This Quote
Post‑publication peer review should follow the same respectful, non‑ad hominem standards as pre‑publication review, allowing authors to respond fairly.
In simple terms: Peer review must stay respectful at all stages.
Key Takeaway
Apply consistent respectful standards to all reviews.
Themes
ethics
fairness
academic integrity
Mood
thoughtful
professional
Type
guideline
policy
When to use this quote
- journal submissions
- conference feedback
- grant proposals
Key Concepts
review standards
communication
Questions to Reflect On
- How can we ensure uniform standards?
- What mechanisms support author response?
A Different Perspective
Enforcing consistency can be difficult across platforms.
![“Some people have set up sort of "gotcha" algorithms that apparently crawl through psychology articles and look for fraudulent p-values [a measure of the likelihood that experimental results weren't a fluke]. But they're including rounding errors that don't change the significance levels of the…” quote by Susan Fiske](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/5b1/susan-fiske-46605_algorithms_some-people-have-set-up-sort-of-gotcha-a_2326797.jpg)
![“The most recent incarnation of [Bob] Dylan has been the traveling journeyman/ charlatan who sings roots music, snarls dark lyrics that make "All Along the Watchtower" sound like a Disney tune, hosts an old-school radio show, and turns up in some unusual places, like ads for Chrysler and Victoria's…” quote by Jay Michaelson](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/734/jay-michaelson-15590_ads_the-most-recent-incarnation-of-bob-dylan_17700.jpg)
