Common law Quote by Stephen R.C. Hicks
““In American law, there is the Constitution and the whole body of common law precedent, and very little of that supports socialism. Consequently, if you are a Left-wing graduate student or professor in literature or law and you are confronted with the Western legal or literary canon, you have two choices. You can take on the opposing traditions, have your students read the great books and the great decisions, and argue with them in your classes. That is very hard work and also very risky—your students might come to agree with the wrong side. Or you can find a way to dismiss the whole tradition, so that you can teach only books that fit your politics. If you are looking for shortcuts, or if you have a sneaking suspicion that the right side might not fare well in the debate, then deconstruction is seductive. Deconstruction allows you to dismiss whole literary and legal traditions as built upon sexist or racist or otherwise exploitative assumptions.””
About This Quote
Source Speech: Lecture on Law and Ideology, 2015
Critiques how deconstruction can be used to reject traditional legal and literary can for ideological reasons.
In simple terms: Deconstruction can be a shortcut to avoid confronting opposing ideas.
Beware of dismissing whole traditions for convenience.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- university classrooms
- legal debates
- political discourse
- academic publishing
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- Do you value tradition over convenience?
- How can you engage with opposing views responsibly?
It may oversimplify complex traditions and ignore valuable insights.