Islam Quote by Robert Spencer
““What about Jerusalem? When discussing the Israeli–Palestinian conflict, pundits and politicians often tell us that Jerusalem is one of the holy cities of Islam—indeed, its third holiest city, right after Mecca and Medina. But in reality, the Islamic claim to Jerusalem is extremely tenuous, based only on a legendary journey of Muhammad—a journey that is at best a dream and at worst a fabrication. The Koran refers to this journey only obliquely and in just one place; Islamic tradition fills in the details and connects Jerusalem with the words of the Koran. But the Koran itself never mentions Jerusalem even once—an exceptionally inconvenient fact for Muslims who claim that the Palestinians must have a share of Jerusalem because the city is sacred to Islam. Muhammad’s famous Night Journey is the basis of the Islamic claim to Jerusalem. The Koran’s sole reference to this journey appears in the first verse of sura 17, which says that Allah took Muhammad from “the Sacred Mosque” in Mecca “to the farthest [al-aqsa] Mosque.” There was no mosque in Jerusalem at this time, so the “farthest” mosque probably wasn’t really the one that now bears that name in Jerusalem, the Al-Aqsa mosque located on the Temple Mount. Nevertheless, Islamic tradition is firm that this mosque was in Jerusalem.””
About This Quote
Source Essay: The Myth of the Islamic Claim to Jerusalem, Robert Spencer, 2010
The argument claims that Islam's holy status for Jerusalem lacks direct Qur'anic support and relies on later tradition, questioning its legitimacy.
In simple terms: Islamic claim to Jerusalem is weak without Qur'anic evidence.
Scrutinize religious claims with primary sources.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- academic debate
- policy making
- interfaith dialogue
- media reporting
- education
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How do we balance respect for faith with critical historical inquiry?
- What role should primary texts play in modern geopolitical claims?
Religious traditions often fill gaps left by scripture, complicating factual assessments.