Skip to content

Big business Quote by Rex E. Lee

“I have no criticism of the basic concept of irrefutable authority. Properly employed, it is the easiest, the surest, and the proper way to resolve conflicts. There is an omnipresent temptation, however, to rely on such authority regardless of its applicability; and I know of no better examples…” quote by Rex E. Lee
Download Open image
““I have no criticism of the basic concept of irrefutable authority. Properly employed, it is the easiest, the surest, and the proper way to resolve conflicts. There is an omnipresent temptation, however, to rely on such authority regardless of its applicability; and I know of no better examples than the scriptures and the Constitution. We find it easy to lapse into the expansive notion that the Constitution, like the gospel, embraces all truth and that it protects and guarantees all that is right, equitable, and just. From that grand premise it is only a short and comfortable leap to the proposition that the Constitution embraces my particular notion of what is right, equitable, and just. The Constitution lends itself to this kind of use because of its breadth. Issues such as foreign aid, fluoridation of water, public versus private education, progressive income tax, to which political party I should belong and which candidate I should support; questions about economic development and environmental quality control; questions about the power of labor unions and the influence of big business in government--all these are issues of great importance. But these questions cannot and ought not to be resolved by simply resorting to irrefutable authority. Neither the Constitution nor the scriptures contain answers to these questions, and under the grand plan of eternal progress it is our responsibility to develop our own skills by working out our own answers through our own thought processes. For example, the Constitution authorizes an income tax, but it neither commands nor forbids an income tax. That is a policy issue on which the Constitution--and the scriptures--are silent. Attempting to resolve our differences of opinion by asserting that if our opponents only understood the scriptures or the Constitution they would see that the whole answer is contained therein only results in foreclosing the careful, rational attention that these issues deserve and require. Resorting to several broad provisions of the Constitution in answer to that kind of question is just plain intellectual laziness. We, of all people, have an obligation to respect the Constitution--to respect it not only for what it is and what it does, but also for what it is not and what it does not do. For in this as in other contexts, improper use of that which is grand can only result in the diminution of its grandeur.””

Rex E. Lee

About This Quote

Source Speech: Remarks on Constitutional Interpretation, 1970

Authority can be useful, but overreliance on it prevents independent reasoning on complex issues.

In simple terms: Don't let authority replace personal thought.

Key Takeaway

Question authority, think critically.

Themes

authority reason politics interpretation critical thinking

Mood

thoughtful analytical cautious

Type

philosophical political advisory

When to use this quote

  • legislative debate
  • court decisions
  • public policy formation
  • educational curricula
  • media commentary

Key Concepts

constitutional law philosophy of law public policy civic responsibility

Questions to Reflect On

  • How do you balance respect for authority with independent analysis?
  • When should you challenge a traditional source?
A Different Perspective

Authority may be misused to silence dissent and oversimplify nuance.

5.0 out of 5 (9 ratings)

More by Rex E. Lee

Explore all 2 Rex E. Lee quotes

More Big business quotes

Browse all 349 Big business quotes