Birth Quote by Philo of Alexandria
““The Illusory Self I am composed of body and soul, I seem to have mind, reason, sense, yet I find none of them my own. For where was my body prior to my birth, and whither will it go when I have departed? Where are the various states produced by the life stages of an illusory self? Where is the newborn babe, the child, the boy, the pubescent, the stripling, the bearded youth, the lad, the full-grown man? Whence came the soul, whither will it go, how long will it be our mate? Can we tell its essential nature? When did we acquire it? Prior to our birth? But we were not then in existence. What of it after death? But then we who are embodied, compounds endowed with quality, shall be no more, but shall hasten to our rebirth, to be with the unbodied, without composition and without quality. But now, inasmuch as we are alive, we are the dominated rather than the rulers, known rather than knowing. The soul knows us, though unknown by us, and imposes commands we are obliged to obey as wervants their mistress. And when it will, it will transact its divorce in court and depart, leaving our home desolate of life. If we press it to remain, it will dissolve our relationship. So subtle is its nature that it furnishes no handle to the body.””
About This Quote
Source Philosophical Treatise: Unknown, ancient Greek text
He questions the nature of the self, body, and soul, pondering identity before birth, after death, and the illusory nature of personal continuity.
In simple terms: We are uncertain about the true nature of our soul and identity.
Reflect on the transient nature of self.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- personal meditation
- academic study
- spiritual practice
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- What defines personal identity over time?
- Can we know the soul's existence?
The argument relies on speculative metaphysics without empirical evidence.