Skip to content

Books Quote by Philip Larkin

“I sit in my room like Miss Havisham, about whom I have been reading this week. Better the Dickens you know than the Dickens you don't know - on the whole I enjoyed it. But I should like to say something about this 'irrepressible vitality', this 'throwing a fresh handful of characters on the fire…” quote by Philip Larkin
Download Open image
““I sit in my room like Miss Havisham, about whom I have been reading this week. Better the Dickens you know than the Dickens you don't know - on the whole I enjoyed it. But I should like to say something about this 'irrepressible vitality', this 'throwing a fresh handful of characters on the fire when it burns low', in fact the whole Dickens method - it strikes me as being less ebullient, creative, vital, than hectic, nervy, panic-stricken. If he were a person I should say 'You don't have to entertain me, you know. I'm quite happy just sitting here.' This jerking of your attention, with queer names, queer characters, aggressive rhythms, piling on adjectives - seems to me to betray basic insecurity in his relation with the reader. How serenely Trollope, for instance, compares. I say in all seriousness that, say what you like about Dickens as an entertainer, he cannot be considered as a real writer at all; not a real novelist. His is the garish gaslit melodramatic barn (writing that phrase makes me wonder if I'm right!) where the yokels gape: outside is the calm measureless world, where the characters of Eliot, Trollope, Austen, Hardy (most of them) and Lawrence (some of them) have their being.””

Philip Larkin

About This Quote

The critic compares Dickens’ frantic, flamboyant style unf other authors’ steadier narratives, questioning his literary depth and suggesting his work feels more like entertainment than serious art.

In simple terms: Dickens is seen as noisy and over‑the‑top, lacking the calm depth of other novelists.

Key Takeaway

Value substance and restraint over sheer theatricality in storytelling.

Themes

literary criticism comparative analysis authorial intent style vs substance

Mood

analytical skeptical

Type

critical comparative

When to use this quote

  • book clubs
  • creative writing courses
  • literary essays
  • publishing decisions

Key Concepts

narrative depth authorial authenticity reader engagement creative vitality

Questions to Reflect On

  • Does popularity equate to literary greatness?
  • Can energetic prose coexist with profound meaning?
A Different Perspective

Dickens’ popularity may stem from mass appeal rather than artistic merit.

2.6 out of 5 (9 ratings)

More by Philip Larkin

Explore all 206 Philip Larkin quotes

More Books quotes

Browse all 59,475 Books quotes