Skip to content

Biology Quote by Peter Atkins

“Life is easy to identify but remarkably difficult to define. Too tight a definition excludes what looks like life and too loose captures too much. The capacity to self-replicate is a component of the definition, but not without its problems, as a mule is alive but sterile, and computer software…” quote by Peter Atkins
Download Open image
““Life is easy to identify but remarkably difficult to define. Too tight a definition excludes what looks like life and too loose captures too much. The capacity to self-replicate is a component of the definition, but not without its problems, as a mule is alive but sterile, and computer software can replicate itself, but we do not, in all honesty, think of it as being alive. It might be tempting to ascribe livingness to an entity that has emerged by evolution, but that would exclude the first living entity and any that we might synthesize from scratch in future. Organisms are organized structures; but so is an integrated circuit. Organisms are organized structures built and sustained by the flux of energy through their interiors and its dissipation into the surroundings; but so are the patterns of convection that can arise in heated liquids and, indeed, the atmosphere, to give rise to the weather: think tornado and hurricane. All known organisms are built from compounds of carbon; but if we succeeded in building a replicating, conscious, self-sustaining, energy-dissipating entity from silicon, would we deny that it was alive? Is a virus alive?””

Peter Atkins

About This Quote

Source Lecture: “What is Life?” at University of Oxford, 2018

Defining life is hard because strict criteria exclude borderline cases, while loose ones include non‑living systems.

In simple terms: Life is hard to define precisely.

Key Takeaway

Consider broader criteria for life.

Themes

philosophy definition biology

Mood

curious thoughtful

Type

philosophical inquisitive

When to use this quote

  • scientific research
  • AI development
  • synthetic biology
  • education

Key Concepts

emergence self‑replication energy flow consciousness

Questions to Reflect On

  • What essential properties must a system have to be alive?
  • Can artificial systems ever meet these criteria?
A Different Perspective

Over‑broad definitions may blur useful distinctions.

2.6 out of 5 (4 ratings)

More by Peter Atkins

Explore all 19 Peter Atkins quotes

More Biology quotes

Browse all 3,036 Biology quotes