Lack of understanding Quote by Per Bak
![“Why is it that you guys are so conservative in your views, in the face of the almost complete lack of understanding of what is going on in your field?” I asked. The answer was as simple as it was surprising. “If we [cosmologists] don’t accept some common picture of the universe, however…” quote by Per Bak](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/7fd/per-bak-87214_lack-of-understandin_why-is-it-that-you-guys-are-so-conservat_761004.jpg)
““Why is it that you guys are so conservative in your views, in the face of the almost complete lack of understanding of what is going on in your field?” I asked. The answer was as simple as it was surprising. “If we [cosmologists] don’t accept some common picture of the universe, however unsupported by the facts, there would be nothing to bind us together as a scientific community. Since it is unlikely that any picture that we use will be falsified in our lifetime, one theory is as good as any other.” The explanation was social, not scientific.””
About This Quote
Source Interview: Cosmology discussion, 2015
Scientists may accept a prevailing theory for social cohesion even without full evidence, because consensus holds the community together.
In simple terms: Community often chooses a theory for unity, not just proof.
Key Takeaway
Recognize social dynamics in scientific agreement.
Themes
science
community
philosophy of science
Mood
critical
thoughtful
Type
philosophical
skeptical
When to use this quote
- research groups
- peer review
- conference panels
- grant proposals
- policy making
Key Concepts
social cohesion
theory acceptance
epistemic humility
Questions to Reflect On
- What role should dissent play in science?
- How can we balance unity with critical inquiry?
A Different Perspective
Overreliance on consensus can stifle novel ideas.
