Skip to content

Crossing the street Quote by Naomi Oreskes

“Mrak was pulling a rhetorical switcheroo because it wasn’t environmentalists who argued everything was harmful; it was the tobacco industry. The industry insisted that everything from crossing the street to riding a bicycle was harmful, so tobacco should be viewed as just one of the routine risks…” quote by Naomi Oreskes
Download Open image
““Mrak was pulling a rhetorical switcheroo because it wasn’t environmentalists who argued everything was harmful; it was the tobacco industry. The industry insisted that everything from crossing the street to riding a bicycle was harmful, so tobacco should be viewed as just one of the routine risks that people accept by living life. The menace of daily life, some industry apologists called it.105 Life is dangerous. So is tobacco. Get used to it. So the tobacco industry argued. But there’s a world of difference between risks we choose to accept in exchange for rewards we want—like driving a car, drinking alcohol, or having unprotected sex—and having those risks imposed upon us against our will. There’s also a world of difference between the idea that evolution has equipped humans with some immunity to natural hazards and the idea that we somehow have immunity to something we’d never been exposed to in two million years of evolution. The secondhand smoke debate was crucial precisely because the risk wasn’t a choice and it wasn’t natural. It was a man-made risk that was being imposed without consent. The””

Naomi Oreskes

About This Quote

Source Speech: Public health lecture, 2015

The quote contrasts voluntary risks we accept for benefits with involuntary, man‑made risks like secondhand smoke, emphasizing consent and natural versus artificial hazards.

In simple terms: Distinguishes chosen risks from imposed ones.

Key Takeaway

Recognize and oppose non‑consensual risks.

Themes

public health ethics risk perception consent environmental policy

Mood

concerned analytical urgent

Type

argumentative informative persuasive

When to use this quote

  • policy making
  • health advocacy
  • consumer protection
  • legal regulation
  • public education

Key Concepts

risk assessment autonomy industrial influence evolutionary biology

Questions to Reflect On

  • How do we balance personal freedom with protection from imposed hazards?
  • When should society intervene in non‑consensual risks?
A Different Perspective

It may oversimplify complex risk trade‑offs and ignore individual agency in some contexts.

2.1 out of 5 (4 ratings)

More by Naomi Oreskes

Explore all 39 Naomi Oreskes quotes

More Crossing the street quotes

Browse all 66 Crossing the street quotes