Inside and outside Quote by Lyn Hejinian
““Writing’s initial situation, its point of origin, is often characterized and always complicated by opposing impulses in the writer and by a seeming dilemma that language creates and then cannot resolve. The writer experiences a conflict between a desire to satisfy a demand for boundedness, for containment and coherence, and a simultaneous desire for free, unhampered access to the world prompting a correspondingly open response to it. Curiously, the term inclusivity is applicable to both, though the connotative emphasis is different for each. The impulse to boundedness demands circumscription and that in turn requires that a distinction be made between inside and outside, between the relevant and the (for the particular writing at hand) confusing and irrelevant—the meaningless. The desire for unhampered access and response to the world (an encyclopedic impulse), on the other hand, hates to leave anything out. The essential question here concerns the writer’s subject position.””
About This Quote
Source Essay: Writing Theory, 1995
The passage describes the writer’s tension between needing structure and yearning for unrestricted exploration, highlighting the dual impulses that shape writing.
In simple terms: Writers balance structure with freedom.
Embrace both constraints and openness in writing.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- creative writing
- academic analysis
- editing
- teaching writing
- personal reflection
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- How do you manage structure and freedom?
- When does constraint enhance creativity?
The need for coherence can limit innovative expression.