Skip to content

Aliens Quote by Lee Spetner

“Dawkins’s advice shows that he didn’t understand probability. . . . Dawkins said that a creature the lives millions of years would have a different feeling for the meaning of the chance of an event than we have. If the alien lives a hundred million years, he could have played very many hands of…” quote by Lee Spetner
Download Open image
““Dawkins’s advice shows that he didn’t understand probability. . . . Dawkins said that a creature the lives millions of years would have a different feeling for the meaning of the chance of an event than we have. If the alien lives a hundred million years, he could have played very many hands of bridge Then, Dawkins said, it would not be unusual for him to see a ‘perfect’ bridge hand where each player was dealt thirteen cards of the same suit. ‘They will expect to be dealt a perfect bridge hand from time to time, and will scarcely trouble to write home about it when it happens.’ He’s wrong. One can easily calculate the chance of Dawkins’s alien experiencing a perfect bridge hand at least once in his lifetime. The shance of getting such a hand in one deal is 4.47 x [10 to the minus 28th power]. If the alien plays 100 bridge hands every day of his life for 100 million years, he would play about 3.65 x [10 to the 12th power] hands. The chance of his seeing a perfect hand at least once in his life is then 1.63 x [10 to the minus 15th power], or about one chance in a quadrillion. That’s less than Dawkins’’ chance of coming to New York for two weeks and winning the lottery twice in a row. Would he bother to write home about it?””

Lee Spetner

About This Quote

Source Book: The God Delusion Debate: A Critical Review, 2006

Probability of rare events remains extremely low even over vast timescales, countering claims that long-lived beings would frequently encounter “perfect” outcomes.

In simple terms: Rare events stay rare despite many trials.

Key Takeaway

Don’t overestimate chances of extraordinary coincidences.

Themes

probability statistics misconception rarity expectation

Mood

skeptical analytical critical

Type

scientific educational

When to use this quote

  • scientific debate
  • educational lectures
  • risk assessment
  • public communication
  • media analysis

Key Concepts

law of large numbers extreme value theory cognitive bias

Questions to Reflect On

  • How do we intuitively misjudge low‑probability events?
  • What safeguards prevent over‑confidence in rare outcomes?
A Different Perspective

Even with billions of trials, the odds of a perfect bridge hand are astronomically low, so expectations should be realistic.

3.2 out of 5 (6 ratings)

More by Lee Spetner

Explore all 16 Lee Spetner quotes

More Aliens quotes

Browse all 1,329 Aliens quotes