Andrew Quote by Laura Sydell
“The FBI wants Apple to write software code to help it break into the iPhone. Apple doesn't want to say this. Andrew Crocker, an attorney with the Electronic Frontier Foundation, or EFF, a digital civil rights group, says the government can't make you say what you don't believe. He looks to a Supreme Court case that began in New Hampshire.”
About This Quote
Source Interview: NPR Tech News, 2023
The government seeks compelled assistance from a tech company, but the company resists on principle and legal grounds.
In simple terms: Government wants Apple to help hack iPhone; Apple refuses.
Key Takeaway
Defend privacy and legal rights.
Themes
privacy
government overreach
tech ethics
Mood
concerned
defiant
serious
Type
legal
political
ethical
When to use this quote
- law enforcement investigations
- corporate compliance
- public policy debates
- court litigation
Key Concepts
first amendment
digital rights
corporate responsibility
Questions to Reflect On
- Should companies comply with government requests that conflict with their policies?
- How do legal precedents shape tech-company obligations?
A Different Perspective
Compulsion may conflict with constitutional protections and corporate values.
![“[Eric]Goldman [a professor at Santa Clara University School of Law] says back in the 1990s, courts began to confront the question of whether software code is a form of speech. Goldman says the answer to that question came in a case called Bernstein v. U.S. Department of Justice. Student Daniel…” quote by Laura Sydell](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/090/laura-sydell-37336_answers_eric-goldman-a-professor-at-santa-clara_419135.jpg)
![“Under [Tim] Cook's leadership, Apple is now using 100 percent renewable energy in the U.S. and China, and it's worked to improve conditions at its manufacturing plants in China.” quote by Laura Sydell](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/1c0/laura-sydell-37336_apples_under-tim-cook-s-leadership-apple-is-now_1105574.jpg)
![“Under [Tim] Cook, Apple has a new product line with the Apple Watch, but it hasn't generated the kind of excitement that the iPod, iPhone or iPad did. Still, Cook can't be called a failure. Under his leadership, the company released a larger version of the iPhone to record sales.” quote by Laura Sydell](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/35c/laura-sydell-37336_apple-watch_under-tim-cook-apple-has-a-new-product-l_1891784.jpg)
![“The Washington Post speaking out against state legislation that he believed would let businesses deny services to gay, lesbian and transgender people. [Tim] Cook himself came out as gay in the pages of Bloomberg Businessweek.” quote by Laura Sydell](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/91d/laura-sydell-37336_cooks_the-washington-post-speaking-out-against_2597935.jpg)
![“When Andrew [Ridgeley] first met my family, he heard my mom calling me "Yorgos." He just abbreviated it to Yog, and unfortunately it stuck. I hated it is a teenager. It was not the most glamorous-sounding name in the world.” quote by George Michael](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/00b/george-michael-1332_andrew_when-andrew-ridgeley-first-met-my-family_12039.jpg)
