Skip to content

Argument Quote by Laura Kipnis

“When sociobiologists start shitting in their backyards with dinner guests in the vicinity, maybe their arguments about innateness over culture will start seeming more persuasive.” quote by Laura Kipnis
Download Open image
““When sociobiologists start shitting in their backyards with dinner guests in the vicinity, maybe their arguments about innateness over culture will start seeming more persuasive. ””

Laura Kipnis

About This Quote

Source Essay: “The Trouble with the ‘Innateness’ Debate”, 2013

Sociobiologists’ personal hypocrisy may make their arguments about nature versus nurture more convincing to observers.

In simple terms: Personal behavior can influence credibility of scientific claims.

Key Takeaway

Question consistency between personal actions and theories.

Themes

ethics science credibility

Mood

critical reflective

Type

philosophical analytical

When to use this quote

  • academic conferences
  • public debates
  • media interviews
  • policy discussions

Key Concepts

nature vs nurture scientific integrity

Questions to Reflect On

  • Does personal conduct invalidate scientific arguments?
  • How can scholars maintain credibility?
A Different Perspective

Critics may view the argument as ad hominem.

2.1 out of 5 (10 ratings)

More by Laura Kipnis

Explore all 9 Laura Kipnis quotes

More Argument quotes

Browse all 3,479 Argument quotes