Arbiter Quote by Lamar S. Smith
“The Supreme Court is not elected, and it is therefore not a proper arbiter of social policy.”
About This Quote
Source Speech: Congressional Testimony, 2015
The Court lacks electoral legitimacy, so its role in shaping social policy is questionable.
In simple terms: Unelected judges shouldn't set social policy.
Key Takeaway
Question the Court's policy influence.
Themes
law
democracy
judiciary
Mood
critical
skeptical
Type
political
analytical
When to use this quote
- policy debates
- civil rights activism
- legal reform
- public opinion
Key Concepts
legitimacy
separation of powers
Questions to Reflect On
- Should elected bodies defer to judicial interpretation?
- How can accountability be ensured?
A Different Perspective
The Court still decides many policies despite being unelected.
![“A nominee [to Supreme Court] must possess the competence, character and temperament to serve on the bench.” quote by Herb Kohl](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/51a/herb-kohl-25520_benches_a-nominee-to-supreme-court-must-possess_40021.jpg)
![“I can't come up with any good reason why they [the INS] would unilaterally disarm.” quote by Lamar S. Smith](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/0fb/lamar-s-smith-28105_come-up_i-can-t-come-up-with-any-good-reason-why_1664799.jpg)
