Civil society Quote by Karl Marx
““In a rational state it would be more appropriate to ensure that a cobbler passed an examination than an executive civil servant; because shoe-making is a craft in the absence of which it is still possible to be a good citizen and a man in society. But the necessary 'knowledge of the state' is a precondition in the absence of which one lives outside the state, cut off from the air one breathes and from oneself. Thus the 'examination' is nothing but a Masonic initiation, the legal recognition of the knowledge of citizenship, the acknowledgement of a privilege. This 'link' between the 'individual' and his 'office', this objective bond between the knowledge of civil society and the knowledge of the state, namely the examination, is nothing but the bureaucratic baptism of knowledge, the official recognition of the transubstantiation of profane knowledge into sacred knowledge (it is plain that in every examination the examiner is omniscient). It is not recorded that Greek and Roman statesmen ever took examinations. But then what is a Roman statesman compared to a Prussian civil servant!””
About This Quote
The author argues that formal examinations create a false sense of legitimacy, turning civic knowledge into a sacred, exclusive rite that separates individuals from true participation in society.
In simple terms: Exams turn civic knowledge into a privileged, almost religious ritual.
Question the authority of bureaucratic certifications.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- applying for public office
- public policy debates
- citizen education programs
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- Do exams truly measure civic virtue?
- What alternatives could ensure responsible citizenship?
The analogy may overstate the mystique of exams and ignore their practical role in competence assessment.