Skip to content

Better world Quote by Jonah Goldberg

“It is my argument that American liberalism is a totalitarian political religion, but not necessarily an Orwellian one. It is nice, not brutal. Nannying, not bullying. But it is definitely totalitarian--or "holistic", if you prefer--in that liberalism today sees no realm of human life that is…” quote by Jonah Goldberg
Download Open image
““It is my argument that American liberalism is a totalitarian political religion, but not necessarily an Orwellian one. It is nice, not brutal. Nannying, not bullying. But it is definitely totalitarian--or "holistic", if you prefer--in that liberalism today sees no realm of human life that is beyond political significance, from what you eat to what you smoke to what you say. Sex is political. Food is political. Sports, entertainment, your inner motives and outer appearance, all have political salience for liberal fascists. Liberals place their faith in priestly experts who know better, who plan, exhort, badger, and scold. They try to use science to discredit traditional notions of religion and faith, but they speak the language of pluralism and spirituality to defend "nontraditional" beliefs. Just as with classical fascism, liberal fascists speak of a "Third Way" between right and left where all good things go together and all hard choices are "false choices". The idea that there are no hard choices--that is, choices between competing goods--is religious and totalitarian because it assumes that all good things are fundamentally compatible. The conservatives or classical liberal vision understands that life is unfair, that man is flawed, and that the only perfect society, the only real utopia, waits for us in the next life. Liberal fascism differs from classical fascism in many ways. I don't deny this. Indeed, it is central to my point. Fascisms differ from each other because they grow out of different soil. What unites them are their emotional or instinctual impulses, such as the quest for community, the urge to "get beyond" politics, a faith in the perfectibility of man and the authority of experts, and an obsession with the aesthetics of youth, the cult of action, and the need for an all powerful state to coordinate society at the national or global level. Most of all, they share the belief--what I call the totalitarian temptation--that with the right amount of tinkering we can realize the utopian dream of "creating a better world".””

Jonah Goldberg

About This Quote

Source Essay: "The Totalitarian Temptation of Liberalism", 2015

He argues modern liberalism functions like a soft totalitarianism, politicizing all aspects of life and demanding expert authority.

In simple terms: Liberalism can become overreaching and controlling.

Key Takeaway

Beware of political overreach.

Themes

politics authority culture liberalism totalitarianism

Mood

critical analytical

Type

political philosophical

When to use this quote

  • policy debates
  • media consumption
  • public discourse

Key Concepts

philosophy political theory social control

Questions to Reflect On

  • What limits should political discourse have?
  • How can expertise be balanced with liberty?
A Different Perspective

Liberalism also values individual freedom, making the claim contested.

2.2 out of 5 (4 ratings)

More by Jonah Goldberg

Explore all 171 Jonah Goldberg quotes

More Better world quotes

Browse all 606 Better world quotes