Another man Quote by John Taylor
““There is also another political party, who desire, through the influence of legislation and coercion, to level the world. To say the least, it is a species of robbery; to some it may appear an honorable one, but, nevertheless, it is robbery. What right has any private man to take by force the property of another? The laws of all nations would punish such a man as a thief. Would thousands of men engaged in the same business make it more honorable? . . . I shall not, here, enter into the various manners of obtaining wealth; but would merely state, that any unjust acquisition of it ought to be punished by law. Wealth is generally the representation of labour, industry, and talent. If one man is industrious, enterprising, diligent, careful, and saves property, and his children follow in his steps, and accumulate wealth; and another man is careless, prodigal, and lazy, and his children inherit his poverty, I cannot conceive upon what principles of justice, the children of the idle and profligate have a right to put their hands into the pockets of those who are diligent and careful, and rob them of their purse. Let this principle exist, and all energy and enterprise would be crushed. Men would be afraid of again accumulating, lest they should again be robbed. Industry and talent would have no stimulant, and confusion and ruin would inevitably follow. Again, if you took men's property without their consent, the natural consequence would be that they would seek to retake it the first opportunity; and this state of things would only deluge the world in blood. So that let any of these measures be carried out, even according to the most sanguine hopes of the parties, they would not only bring distress upon others, but also upon themselves; certainly they would not bring about the peace of the world.””
About This Quote
Source Book: Principles of Political Economy, John Taylor, 19th century
The quote argues that coercive redistribution of wealth is unjust theft, discouraging industry and leading to conflict.
In simple terms: Stealing others' property harms society and stifles effort.
Protect property rights to encourage productivity.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- tax policy
- wealth transfer
- government regulation
- inheritance law
- social welfare programs
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- What mechanisms can ensure fair wealth distribution without coercion?
- How do we balance social safety nets with incentives for hard work?
If redistribution is done fairly and voluntarily, it may reduce inequality without violating rights.