Skip to content

High fidelity Quote by John D. Barrow

“In a Newtonian world, all physical quantities, like energy and spin, can take on any values whatsoever. They range over the entire continuum of numbers. Hence, if one were to form a 'Newtonian hydrogen atom' by setting an electron in circular orbit around a single proton then the electron could…” quote by John D. Barrow
Download Open image
““In a Newtonian world, all physical quantities, like energy and spin, can take on any values whatsoever. They range over the entire continuum of numbers. Hence, if one were to form a 'Newtonian hydrogen atom' by setting an electron in circular orbit around a single proton then the electron could move in a closed orbit of any radius because it could possess any orbital speed. As a result, every pair of electrons and protons that came together would be different. The electrons would find themselves in some randomly different orbit. The chemical properties of each of the atoms would be different and their sizes would be different. Even if one were to create an initial population in which the electrons' speeds were the same and the radii of their orbits identical, they would each drift away from their starting state in differing ways as they suffered the buffetings of radiation and other particles. There could not exist a well-defined element called hydrogen with universal properties, even if there existed universal populations of identical electrons and protons. Quantum mechanics shows us why there are identical collective structures. The quantization of energy allows it to come only in discrete packets, and so when an electron and a proton come together there is a single state for them to reside in. The same configuration arises for every pair of electrons and protons that you care to choose. This universal state is what we call the hydrogen atom. Moreover, once it exists, its properties do not drift because of the plethora of tiny perturbations from other particles. In order to change the orbit of the electron around the proton, it has to be hit by a sizeable perturbation that is sufficient to change its energy by a whole quantum packet. Thus the quantization of energy lies at the root of the repeatability of structure in the physical world and the high fidelity of all identical phenomena in the atomic world. With the quantum ambiguity of the microscopic world the macroscopic world would not be intelligible, nor indeed would there be intelligences to take cognisance of any such a totally heterodox non-quantum reality.””

John D. Barrow

About This Quote

Source Book: The Origin of the Universe by John D. Barrow, 1991

Quantum quantization ensures that particles occupy discrete energy levels, creating identical atoms and repeatable physical phenomena.

In simple terms: Quantized energy makes atoms identical.

Key Takeaway

Recognize that discrete rules create consistency.

Themes

physics quantum mechanics identity structure repeatability

Mood

curious analytical inquisitive

Type

scientific explanatory philosophical

When to use this quote

  • chemistry labs
  • materials engineering
  • nanotechnology
  • education
  • fundamental research

Key Concepts

energy quantization atomic stability fundamental constants

Questions to Reflect On

  • How does quantization affect macroscopic properties?
  • What would happen if energy were continuous?
A Different Perspective

Quantum effects can be disrupted by extreme conditions, limiting perfect repeatability.

2.7 out of 5 (9 ratings)

More by John D. Barrow

Explore all 109 John D. Barrow quotes

More High fidelity quotes

Browse all 17 High fidelity quotes