Others Quote by John C. Calhoun
“What is it but a cunningly devised scheme to take from one State and to give to another - to replenish the treasury of some of the States from the pockets of the people of the others; in reality, to make them support the governments and pay the debts of other States as well as their own?”
About This Quote
Source Treatise: South Carolina Senate Speech, 1825
The proposal shifts wealth from one state to another, forcing people to fund both their own and others’ debts, exposing exploitation in fiscal policy.
In simple terms: A scheme moves money between states, making citizens pay for multiple debts.
Key Takeaway
Beware policies fiscal policies that redistribute wealth unfairly.
Themes
economics
politics
taxation
exploitation
fiscal policy
Mood
skeptical
analytical
inquisitive
Type
historical
economic
political
When to use this quote
- budget planning
- tax reform debates
- citizen advocacy
Key Concepts
redistributive taxation
interstate debt
public finance
Questions to Reflect On
- Who truly benefits from inter‑state wealth transfers?
- How can fairness be ensured in national fiscal policies?
A Different Perspective
Such schemes can cause resentment and economic instability if not carefully managed.
