Congregation Quote by James Alison
“I'm honestly not sure that I've ever tried to talk as a theologian about "homosexual acts," per se. My disagreement with the current teaching of the Roman Congregations is about what I consider to be their fundamentally flawed premise of the objectively disordered nature of the inclination.”
About This Quote
He questions the doctrine that labels same‑sex attraction as disordered, arguing the premise is flawed.
In simple terms: He doubts the teaching that gay acts are inherently wrong.
Key Takeaway
Challenge assumptions about moral teachings.
Themes
theology
ethics
human sexuality
Mood
thoughtful
critical
Type
theological
philosophical
When to use this quote
- religious debate
- pastoral counseling
- academic discourse
- personal belief
Key Concepts
doctrinal critique
moral philosophy
inclusion
Questions to Reflect On
- What evidence supports or refutes the premise?
- How can faith communities reconcile doctrine with lived experience?
A Different Perspective
May not address all theological perspectives.
![“[Joseph Ratzinger] is a man who as the prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith had everything in his hands. He conducted all the investigations, and went on, went on, went on, until he couldn't go any further in the execution.” quote by Pope Francis](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/e74/pope-francis-85_congregation_joseph-ratzinger-is-a-man-who-as-the-pre_146136.jpg)