Ads Quote by Henry Rosovsky
“Harvard introduced the now famous ad hoc system whereby a group of experts in the field of the faculty member to be promoted are consulted concerning the stature of that scholar. This move made the opinion within the field, rather than the clubby relationship within the department, the determining factor in the promotion of professors.”
About This Quote
Source Speech: Harvard Faculty Meeting, 1970s (historical account)
Shifted promotion decisions from departmental politics to expert peer review, emphasizing merit.
In simple terms: Merit over politics.
Key Takeaway
Prioritise expertise.
Themes
academia
meritocracy
governance
Mood
analytical
critical
Type
reflective
academic
When to use this quote
- Hiring committees
- tenure reviews
- research funding
- departmental elections
Key Concepts
Peer review
institutional reform
Questions to Reflect On
- How can bias be reduced in expert panels?
- What safeguards ensure fairness?
A Different Perspective
Peer review may still be biased by networks.
![“A significant contribution to science pedagogy and to the scholarship of teaching and learning. ... [W]ill be of interest to researchers in the area of science education and to college and university faculty members who seek to improve their teaching.” quote by David W. Oxtoby](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/939/david-w-oxtoby-231594_areas_a-significant-contribution-to-science-pe_1969207.jpg)
![“The most recent incarnation of [Bob] Dylan has been the traveling journeyman/ charlatan who sings roots music, snarls dark lyrics that make "All Along the Watchtower" sound like a Disney tune, hosts an old-school radio show, and turns up in some unusual places, like ads for Chrysler and Victoria's…” quote by Jay Michaelson](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/734/jay-michaelson-15590_ads_the-most-recent-incarnation-of-bob-dylan_17700.jpg)
