Good Quote by George Herbert
“For the same man to be an heretick and a good subject, is incompossible.”
About This Quote
He claims it is impossible for one person to be both a heretic and a good subject, implying a contradiction between dissenting belief and acceptable conformity.
In simple terms: Heretic cannot be a good subject.
Key Takeaway
Contradiction between dissent and conformity.
Themes
heretical belief
conformity
paradox
social order
Mood
critical
skeptical
Type
political
philosophical
When to use this quote
- A student challenging curriculum standards
- A whistleblower within a corporation
- A political dissident seeking office
Key Concepts
political philosophy
social control
Practical Applications
- Recognize when dissent is suppressed
- Navigate institutional expectations while maintaining integrity
Questions to Reflect On
- Can dissent coexist with constructive participation?
- What defines a 'good subject' in a pluralistic society?
A Different Perspective
History shows many heretics who were also exemplary citizens or leaders.
![“In the house of a Fidler, all fiddle. [In the house of the fiddler all fiddle.]” quote by George Herbert](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/b11/george-herbert-107_fiddle_in-the-house-of-a-fidler-all-fiddle-in-t_4810.jpg)
