Skip to content

Freud Quote by Gary Valentine Lachman

“Jung had had enough, and in his reply he made clear his disgust with Freud’s infuriating practice of treating criticism of his ideas as mere psychological resistance to his infallibility. Jung had already complained that “the majority of psychoanalysts misuse psychoanalysis to devalue other people…” quote by Gary Valentine Lachman
Download Open image
““Jung had had enough, and in his reply he made clear his disgust with Freud’s infuriating practice of treating criticism of his ideas as mere psychological resistance to his infallibility. Jung had already complained that “the majority of psychoanalysts misuse psychoanalysis to devalue other people and their progress by insinuations about complexes,”19 and now he dotted the i’s and crossed the t’s. Treating his followers like patients, he told Freud, was a “blunder” that produced “either slavish sons or impudent puppies.” “I am objective enough to see through your little trick,” he told the master. “You go around sniffing out all the symptomatic actions in your vicinity, thus reducing everyone to the level of your sons and daughters who blushingly admit the existence of their faults. Meanwhile you remain on top as a father, sitting pretty. For sheer obsequiousness nobody dares to pluck the prophet by the beard and inquire for once what you would say to a patient with a tendency to analyse the analyst instead of himself.” “You see, my dear Professor, so long as you hand out this stuff I don’t give a damn for my symptomatic actions; they shrink to nothing compared with the formidable beam in my brother Freud’s eye.”20””

Gary Valentine Lachman

About This Quote

Source Book: Jung and Freud: The Unfinished Dialogue, 1995

Jung criticizes Freud’s authoritarian stance, accusing him of reducing patients to mere subjects and stifling genuine analysis.

In simple terms: Jung sees Freud’s method as oppressive and self‑serving.

Key Takeaway

Question authority, seek authentic dialogue.

Themes

psychology authority analysis freud vs jung

Mood

critical analytical

Type

philosophical psychological

When to use this quote

  • therapy sessions
  • academic debates
  • personal introspection

Key Concepts

critical theory psychoanalysis power dynamics

Questions to Reflect On

  • What would a truly collaborative analysis look like?
  • How can one balance respect for tradition with critical inquiry?
A Different Perspective

Freud’s influence may still dominate, limiting alternative perspectives.

3.8 out of 5 (5 ratings)

More by Gary Valentine Lachman

Explore all 46 Gary Valentine Lachman quotes

More Freud quotes

Browse all 384 Freud quotes