Capital punishment Quote by Frederick Engels
““No soldiers, no gendarmes or police, no nobles, kings, regents, prefects, or judges, no prisons, no lawsuits - and everything takes its orderly course. All quarrels and disputes are settled by the whole of the community affected, by the gens or the tribe, or by the gentes among themselves; only as an extreme and exceptional measure is blood revenge threatened-and our capital punishment is nothing but blood revenge in a civilized form, with all the advantages and drawbacks of civilization. Although there were many more matters to be settled in common than today - the household is maintained by a number of families in common, and is communistic, the land belongs to the tribe, only the small gardens are allotted provisionally to the households - yet there is no need for even a trace of our complicated administrative apparatus with all its ramifications. The decisions are taken by those concerned, and in most cases everything has been already settled by the custom of centuries. There cannot be any poor or needy - the communal household and the gens know their responsibilities towards the old, the sick, and those disabled in war. All are equal and free - the women included. There is no place yet for slaves, nor, as a rule, for the subjugation of other tribes.””
About This Quote
Source Essay: The Condition of the Working Class in England, Frederick Engels, 1845
A communal, egalitarian society without hierarchical institutions would resolve disputes peacefully, but such a system is idealistic and may lack practical mechanisms.
In simple terms: Communal equality could replace institutions, but practicality is doubtful.
Consider balance between communal ideals and practical governance.
Themes
Mood
Type
When to use this quote
- community decision‑making
- conflict resolution
- social policy
- resource sharing
- local governance
Key Concepts
Questions to Reflect On
- Can a fully communal system function today?
- What safeguards prevent abuse in such societies?
Idealism may overlook human conflict and administrative needs.