Aquinas Quote by Edward Feser
“Dawkins’s problem is that he doesn’t know the difference between probabilistic empirical theorizing and strict metaphysical demonstration, and thus misreads an attempt at the latter as if it were the former. That is not to say that Aquinas might not be mistaken at some point in the argument – though obviously I don’t think he is – but if you’re going to show that he is, you first need to understand what kind of argument he is giving, and thus what kind of mistake he’d be making if he’s made one at all.”
About This Quote
Source Book: The Cambridge Companion to Aquinas, 2005
Confusing statistical inference with philosophical proof leads to misreading arguments and attributing errors incorrectly.
In simple terms: Mixing empirical and metaphysical reasoning causes misunderstanding.
Key Takeaway
Distinguish evidence types before critiquing.
Themes
philosophy
logic
argumentation
Mood
analytical
critical
Type
philosophical
academic
When to use this quote
- academic debate
- philosophical critique
- theology discussion
- science vs religion dialogue
Key Concepts
probabilistic reasoning
metaphysical demonstration
argument analysis
Questions to Reflect On
- How do you tell empirical from metaphysical claims?
- What risks arise from conflating the two?
A Different Perspective
Overemphasis on categorization may overlook nuanced positions.
![“Mr. Dawkins' assertions are self-refuting- ie. Actual infinity vs. potential infinity easily makes the most reasonable argument for theism and a Deity. Now, the argument for the Creator God of Christianity requires much more time, energy, and logical effort." ~R. Alan Woods [2007]” quote by R. Alan Woods](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/215/r-alan-woods-1455_apologetics_mr-dawkins-assertions-are-self-refuting_801373.jpg)
![“I just would like to say that over more than a quarter-century as a scientist and a believer, I find absolutely nothing in conflict between agreeing with Richard [Dawkins] in practically all of his conclusions about the natural world, and also saying that I am still able to accept and embrace the…” quote by Richard Dawkins](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/177/richard-dawkins-115_able_i-just-would-like-to-say-that-over-more_2074968.jpg)
![“I don't see that [Richard] Dawkins' basic account of evolution is incompatible with God's having designed it.” quote by Richard Dawkins](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/6d4/richard-dawkins-115_accounts_i-don-t-see-that-richard-dawkins-basic-a_1945558.jpg)
![“Preaching Christianity to skeptics without first setting out the praeambula fidei [preambles of faith], and then complaining when they don’t accept it, is like yelling in English at someone who only speaks Chinese, and then dismissing him as a fool when he doesn’t understand you. In both cases…” quote by Edward Feser](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/3fc/edward-feser-41693_accepting_preaching-christianity-to-skeptics-witho_969999.jpg)
