Skip to content

Books Quote by Deirdre McCloskey

“Virginia Woolf wrote famously, “About December 1910 human nature changed.” Well, one doubts it. What did change, and has been changing all through the closing decades of the 19th century, is that the intelligentsia became increasingly alienated from the bourgeois world from which it sprung, and…” quote by Deirdre McCloskey
Download Open image
““Virginia Woolf wrote famously, “About December 1910 human nature changed.” Well, one doubts it. What did change, and has been changing all through the closing decades of the 19th century, is that the intelligentsia became increasingly alienated from the bourgeois world from which it sprung, and wished to become something Higher. It wished to make novels difficult and technical – think of Woolf or Joyce – to keep them out of the hands of the uneducated and to elevate the intelligentsia to a new clerisy, a new aristocracy of the spirit. Similarly in painting, music, and philosophy. It wished to make everything difficult and technical, and it succeeded. [Economists Lawrence] Klein, [Paul] Samuelson, and [Jan] Tinbergen were middle-period modernists. The vices of modernism come from the master vice of Pride, the vice so characteristic of an actual or wannabe aristocracy. It is prideful overreaching to think that social engineering can work, that a smart lad at a blackboard can outwit the wisdom of the world or the ages, that a piece of machinery like statistical significance can tell you how big or small a number is.””

Deirdre McCloskey

About This Quote

Source Essay: The Rise of Modernism, 1990s

Modernism’s drive for elite distinction created elitist art and economics, rooted in pride and overconfidence in technical mastery.

In simple terms: Elitist art and economics stem from pride and overconfidence.

Key Takeaway

Beware prideful overreach in intellectual pursuits.

Themes

elitism pride modernism intellectualism social engineering

Mood

critical reflective skeptical

Type

philosophical critical

When to use this quote

  • academic circles
  • art criticism
  • economic policy design
  • philosophical debates
  • media analysis

Key Concepts

cultural hierarchy technical elitism statistical significance social engineering intellectual arrogance

Questions to Reflect On

  • How does pride shape cultural movements?
  • Can technical expertise be democratized?
A Different Perspective

It can alienate broader audiences and stifle inclusive progress.

2.6 out of 5 (5 ratings)

More by Deirdre McCloskey

Explore all 2 Deirdre McCloskey quotes

More Books quotes

Browse all 59,485 Books quotes