Assault Quote by David Cannadine
“On several occasions, we are informed that the professional ideal 'took steps', 'organised assaults', and 'selected social problems'. But this is anthropomorphic metaphor implausibly masquerading as historical explanation.”
About This Quote
Source Article: The Myth of the Professional Ideal, 2018
Historical narratives often use anthropomorphic metaphors, which can mislead by attributing human motives to complex events.
In simple terms: Metaphors can distort historical explanations.
Key Takeaway
Critically evaluate metaphorical language in history.
Themes
history
metaphor
analysis
critical thinking
Mood
analytical
skeptical
Type
academic
philosophical
When to use this quote
- Writing academic papers
- teaching history
- reading scholarly articles
- debating historiography
Key Concepts
Narrative framing
anthropomorphism
historical methodology
Questions to Reflect On
- What are the limits of metaphor in explaining history?
- How can we balance vivid storytelling with factual accuracy?
A Different Perspective
Metaphors can simplify complex causes, risking oversimplification.
![“...it was always our view that in order to attain this [proletarian revolution] and the other far more important aims of the future social revolution, the working class must first take possession of the organised political power of the state and by its aid crush the resistance of the capitalist…” quote by Friedrich Engels](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/458/friedrich-engels-8301_aids_it-was-always-our-view-that-in-order-to_258810.jpg)
![“The globe of this earth … [is] … not just a machine but also a organised body as it has a regenerative power.” quote by James Hutton](https://sms4smile.com/quotes/img-quotes/5d5/james-hutton-28638_body_the-globe-of-this-earth-is-not-just-a-ma_200947.jpg)
