Skip to content

Fantasy Quote by David Brin

“While I have the floor, here's a question that's been bothering me for some time. Why do so few writers of heroic or epic fantasy ever deal with the fundamental quandary of their novels . . . that so many of them take place in cultures that are rigid, hierarchical, stratified, and in essence…” quote by David Brin
Download Open image
““While I have the floor, here's a question that's been bothering me for some time. Why do so few writers of heroic or epic fantasy ever deal with the fundamental quandary of their novels . . . that so many of them take place in cultures that are rigid, hierarchical, stratified, and in essence oppressive? What is so appealing about feudalism, that so many free citizens of an educated commonwealth like ours love reading about and picturing life under hereditary lords? Why should the deposed prince or princess in every clichéd tale be chosen to lead the quest against the Dark Lord? Why not elect a new leader by merit, instead of clinging to the inbred scions of a failed royal line? Why not ask the pompous, patronizing, "good" wizard for something useful , such as flush toilets, movable type, or electricity for every home in the kingdom? Given half a chance, the sons and daughters of peasants would rather not grow up to be servants. It seems bizarre for modern folk to pine for a way of life our ancestors rightfully fought desperately to escape.””

David Brin

About This Quote

Source Interview: Q&A with David Brin, 2023

The quote critiques the persistent use of feudal settings in fantasy, questioning why oppressive hierarchies remain attractive and urging more meritocratic, technologically progressive worlds.

In simple terms: Fantasy often repeats feudal tropes, ignoring modern values.

Key Takeaway

Consider reimagining fantasy with equitable societies.

Themes

fantasy literature worldbuilding social critique political philosophy genre conventions

Mood

thoughtful critical inquisitive

Type

analytical philosophical

When to use this quote

  • author panels
  • writing workshops
  • genre analysis
  • creative brainstorming

Key Concepts

feudalism hierarchy meritocracy technology class struggle

Questions to Reflect On

  • How can writers balance familiar tropes with progressive ideals?
  • What would a merit‑based fantasy world look like?
A Different Perspective

Feudal settings provide familiar conflict structures that many readers find compelling.

4.7 out of 5 (10 ratings)

More by David Brin

Explore all 142 David Brin quotes

More Fantasy quotes

Browse all 5,471 Fantasy quotes