Skip to content

Poor family Quote by Cornel West

“The new black conservatives claim that transfer payments to the black needy engender a mentality of dependence which undercuts the value of self-reliance and of the solidity of the black poor family. They fail to see that the welfare state was a historic compromise between progressive forces…” quote by Cornel West
Download Open image
““The new black conservatives claim that transfer payments to the black needy engender a mentality of dependence which undercuts the value of self-reliance and of the solidity of the black poor family. They fail to see that the welfare state was a historic compromise between progressive forces seeking broad subsistence rights and conservative forces arguing for unregulated markets. Therefore it should come as no surprise that the welfare state possesses many flaws. The reinforcing of 'dependent mentalities' and the unsettling of the family are two such flaws. But simply to point out these rather obvious shortcomings does not justify cutbacks in the welfare state. In the face of high black unemployment, these cutbacks will not promote self-reliance or strong black families but will only produce even more black cultural disorientation and more devastated black households. This is so because without jobs or incentives to be productive citizens the black poor become even more prone toward criminality, drugs, and alcoholism- the major immediate symptoms of the pervasive black communal and cultural chaos.””

Cornel West

About This Quote

Source Essay: “The Welfare State and Black Communities,” 2021

Welfare policies can unintentionally foster dependence, but cutting them without alternatives harms families and increases social problems

In simple terms: Welfare has both benefits and drawbacks, especially for marginalized groups

Key Takeaway

Address systemic inequality while reforming aid

Themes

justice economics family dynamics

Mood

critical analytical

Type

political philosophical

When to use this quote

  • policy reform
  • community programs
  • education initiatives

Key Concepts

dependency social policy racial equity

Questions to Reflect On

  • What alternatives can reduce dependency while supporting families?
  • How can policy balance market freedom with social safety nets?
A Different Perspective

Reforms must avoid deepening poverty; unintended consequences can arise

3.1 out of 5 (8 ratings)

More by Cornel West

Explore all 400 Cornel West quotes

More Poor family quotes

Browse all 87 Poor family quotes