Skip to content

Metaphysical Quote by Christoph Schönborn

“What constitutes the various species? [...] Here we come up against the perennial question of human thought, which even evolutionism cannot evade: we can only ever consider single, concrete individuals—this dog, and that spruce tree, this grasshopper, and that man. “Humanity” is not something we…” quote by Christoph Schönborn
Download Open image
““What constitutes the various species? [...] Here we come up against the perennial question of human thought, which even evolutionism cannot evade: we can only ever consider single, concrete individuals—this dog, and that spruce tree, this grasshopper, and that man. “Humanity” is not something we can see, nor is “catness” or “spruce-ness”. Behind these considerations lies the perennial dispute about “universals”. Is there really such a thing as “humanity”, or are these just “nomina nuda”, as Umberto Eco says in the final sentence of his famous novel The Name of the Rose? Nominalism, which was widespread in the fifteenth century, says that we cannot actually know anything properly. Is there such a thing as “man” as a kind of creature, a species? I have the impression that many scientists do not really like this question because it is too philosophical. It leads us unavoidably into metaphysics. Is there such a thing as a “species”? Are there such things as “beings” at all?””

Christoph Schönborn

About This Quote

Source Speech: Lecture on Philosophy of Universals, 2020

The passage questions whether abstract concepts like “humanity” truly exist or are merely linguistic constructs, highlighting the tension between nominalism and the desire to categorize reality.

In simple terms: We may not truly know universal categories; they could be just words.

Key Takeaway

Question the reality of abstract categories.

Themes

philosophy language ontology metaphysics science

Mood

inquisitive analytical skeptical

Type

philosophical theoretical

When to use this quote

  • academic debates
  • scientific classification
  • ethical discussions
  • education curricula

Key Concepts

nominalism universals species concept

Questions to Reflect On

  • Do we need universal concepts for communication?
  • How does nominalism affect scientific practice?
A Different Perspective

It may ignore practical usefulness of categories in everyday life.

2.4 out of 5 (10 ratings)

More by Christoph Schönborn

Explore all 10 Christoph Schönborn quotes

More Metaphysical quotes

Browse all 534 Metaphysical quotes